Soups

Noank Style Clam Chowder – Clear broth style in the traditional manner–a local legend!

New England Style Clam Chowder – Creamy version of our Noank style.

Lobster Bisque – Thick, rich, creamy bisque with the essence of fresh lobster.

From the Raw Bar

Clams on the Half – Shell Freshly shucked and served with a lemon wedge, cocktail sauce, and oyster crackers.

Oysters on the Half – Shell Purity tested from certified growing beds. Served icy cold with cocktail sauce and lemon wedge. Supply changes daily, call for today’s offerings.

Shrimp Cocktail – Six large shrimp served with lemon and cocktail sauce.

Starters

  • Fritters 1/2 Dozen, Golden brown–clammy flavor! Noank style fritters served with dipping sauce.
  • Crab Cakes Two fresh lump crabmneat sautéed with just the right amount of breading and seasoning. Served with our own special dipping sauce.
  • Stuffed Clams Three deep ocean quahog shells stuffed with a mixture of finely minced clams and herbs in a bread base. Served with cocktail sauce.
  • Steamed Clams Sweet, small steamers specifically processed for us–grit free.
  • Mussels A bountiful bowlful fresh from the deep-water beds of the North Atlantic.
  • Marty’s Mussels Steamed in garlic and wine! Yum!
  • Bacon Wrapped Scallops Eight juicy scallops wrapped in bacon.
  • Fried Calamari Rhode Island style with banana peppers, served with marinara sauce.
  • Mozzarella Sticks Six with marinara sauce.
  • Popcorn Shrimp Delicious fried shrimp served with cocktail sauce.
  • Mac and Cheese Bites

Salads

add chicken, shrimp, salmon or scallops to any salad.

  • Wedge Salad Bacon, gorgonzola, and bleu cheese dressing.
  • Caesar Salad Classic Caesar.
  • Lobster Tail Salad Hot or cold.
  • Pearl Street Salad Bibb lettuce, avocado, mango, walnuts, topped with seared scallops and shrimp and white balsamic vinaigrette.

Costello’s Classics

Served with fries and coleslaw.

  • Whole Clam Dinner Whole belly clams shipped straight to Costello’s from the cold clear waters of the Bay of Fundy.
  • Clam Strip Dinner A generous serving of battered and fried clam strips. One of our favorites!
  • Fish & Chips Dinner Our version of a favorite! Two generous pieces of center cut North Atlantic cod, batter fried to peak flavor.
  • Scallop Dinner Sweet and juicy sea scallops full of flavor.
  • Shrimp Dinner Seven plump beauties–and we kick ’em up a notch! Hand breaded and fried.
  • Coconut Shrimp Dinner Coconut breaded plump shrimp served with a sweet oriental dipping sauce.
  • Oyster Dinner Freshly shucked oysters, seasoned and fried.
  • Fried Lobster Tail Dinner
  • C’s Triple Mixed Dinner Mix any three above!
  • Lobster Dinner 1 1/8 pound lobster served with coleslaw and chips.
  • Salmon Dinner

On The Shells

Served on a flour tortilla with cabbage, mango salsa, and Costello’s housemade taco sauce. Served with Costello’s fries. Gluten free tacos and corn tortillas available.

  • Fish Tacos Fried or grilled cod.
  • Chicken Tacos Grilled chicken breast.
  • Vegetable Tacos Cucumber, roasted red peppers, avocado, corn, and fetta.
  • Shrimp Tacos Cajun or garlic.
  • Tuna Tacos Ahi tuna steak.

Sides

  • Costello’s Fries Thin and crispy–the tastiest around! A heaping tray full.
  • Onion Rings Hand breaded.
  • Corn on the Cob Steamed and served with drawn butter.

All Ashore!

  • Burger Juicy burger–cheese, bacon, lettuce, tomato, onion.
  • Hot Dog Premium quality hot dog. All beef.
  • Chicken Sandwich grilled chicken breast, lettuce, tomato, onion, mayo and cheese.
  • Chicken Tenders choose between an order of three or six.

Seafood Rolls

  • Hot Lobster Roll A quarter pound of pure succulent lobster meat drizzled with melted butter and served on a toasted roll.
  • Lobster Salad Roll Nearly a quarter pound of luscious lobster meat lightly dressed with our special dressing dressing and a sprinkle of diced celery added.
  • Whole Belly Clam Roll A clam fanatics favorite on a toasted roll!
  • Clam Strip Roll Classic clam strips on a toasted roll!
  • Tuna Melt Cheese meets tuna salad sandwich.
  • Fish Sandwich A plump tasty center cut of North Atlantic cod, batter fried and served on a toasted bun.

Little Snappers

Served with chips or baby carrots.

  • PB&J
  • Grilled Cheese
  • Macaroni and Cheese

Beverages

  • Sodas
  • Coffee, Decaf or Hot Tea
  • Iced Coffee or Iced Decaf
  • Fresh Brewed Iced Tea
  • Bottled Water
  • Sparkling Smart Water
  • Strawberry Sorbet Lemonade
  • Milkshakes
  • Kid’s Shakes

Desserts

  • Ice Cream Gifford’s ice cream! Check our specials board for today’s flavors.
  • Fried Dough With powdered sugar or cinnamon sugar and your choice of ice cream on top.
  • Fried Smuckers PB&J with Strawberry Ice Cream